“ I ordered a Gyro and Greek salad. Both were delicious. Staff was friendly and accommodating. Definitely will go back. ”

“ Saw this place online & had to try it! So happy I did because it seriously was so good! Everything we ordered was fresh and flavorful! My boyfriend got the mixed meat gyro with chicken/beef/lamb & really liked it! I got the hummus & falafel dinner & we split the feta & spinach pierogis.. both were delicious! The service was wonderful too, the woman at the front was so kind! I will definitely be coming back! :) ”

“ Addictive gyros! I can't speak for anything else on the menu right now but the gyros. The gyro was the first item recommended by the friendly host and it rocks. The tender gyro meat, made up of ground lamb and beef, is spiced well and rested on a pillowy pita bread with fresh vegetables and creamy tzatziki. The fries could be a little more crispy and salted, if being truly honest, I think next time I'll see what other side options are available. There are also other intriguing menu items like the Greek style pizzas which I hope to try on a future visit. Finally Yelp had the hours listed incorrectly and I visited on a night they were not open but that is hardly the merchant's fault. Speaking to the owner, best to call on Mondays to see if they are open. I'll be back again for the gyro really soon! ”

“ Delicious food every time from salads, hummus, gyro/meat, or pizza! The customer service is excellent where you feel like you are the only customer in the world when being served. This creates a comfortable environment whether dining in or takeout. ”

“ Stopped by today with my wife and son. Started with fried zucchini sticks, and mozzarella sticks - both were great appetizers. The wife and I also had the Avgolemono -- Greek Lemon Chicken Soup. It was fantastically good. We decided on Salads today (prob because it's been so hot lately). I had the greek salad with grilled lamb, my wife opted for the village salad, while my son went for a caesar salad with gyro meat. All three salads were dead on perfect. Surprisingly we managed to leave room for dessert. We opted for the Galaktoboureko, which is a Greek custard. I've had this in several places. Pi does it a little different with the flaky philo dough on top. It's a different spin on the the dessert, but very good nonetheless. Personally I like the traditional (honey/butter) topping. To be fair, this probably saved me about 200 calories :) The inside of the cozy restaurant is decorated nicely with plates (I assume from Greece) on the wall. It's very tasteful, and reminds me of some of the other mediterranean places I have been to. The owner (Demetrius), who is really sweet man, treated us like family. He was also our server today, but I suspect that would not have been the case if it was during a busier day. We had a little chat after the meal, and ensured him we would definitely be back for another meal (prob many more to come). The place also serves pizza, sandwiches, and a host of other foods. Everything was delicious. You can tell there is a lot of love and attention in each meal. ”

“ Stopped in for lunch. Friendly service and tasty food. Was pleasantly surprised. We ordered the Greek salad, spicy feta dip, and the beef/lamb gyro. The gyro and the dip were our favorites. Would stop there again if in the area. ”

“ So fresh and amazing service The woman running the front is the sweetest and has the best recommendations. It was my first time, and based off the reviews on Yelp, I chose to the traditional Greek salad with falafel. The salad was so good and made with the freshest ingredients. Oh and the baklava !!! So flaky, sweet and yummy. Keep in mind that things are on a the more expensive side, but you're paying for the quality you are receiving. I was very pleased with my order, and the service I received while I was there. The woman also recommended I try moussaka, so I'm hoping to try that the next time I go there. Small critique, I'm pretty sure the Greek salad is supposed to come with dolmades, based on the menu description and the pictures on Yelp, however my salad did not have them. I will have to order those next time as well. ”

“ The thing about this place is they import the feta, tomatoes and most of their ingredients directly from Greece and you can taste the difference The food is absolutely delicious.. .. they also have tiropita which is my favorite. The staff is also great and in particular Aphrodite - always let me know the budget and stories about Greece .. ”

“ I couldn't waste any time in reviewing this Greek spot found in the plaza at the corner of route 130 and klockner rd in Hamilton. Why give the location so early in the review? Because you need to get in your car and get some Pi Greek American cuisine down your gullet ASAP! After a zoom job interview I felt a mix of stress and that aftermath of relief, hope and excitement. As a way of prematurely celebrating the future, I placed a call to this eatery and a friendly voice guided me through the different options. Obviously I'm familiar with the standards like gyros, souvlaki, & baklava. However I was intrigued by their "Greek pizza." Was it "New England style" pizza like what you'll see in small towns in mass, Vermont etc? Was it the usual American-Italian foldable Jersey slices simply topped with gyro meat? What about a big pita that pretends to be a pizza? Well, their Greek pizza doesn't fit any of those molds, but what it is is a must get! It's on a thin-medium crust that isn't quite pita but also isn't 00 semolina. It's a perfect vessel for the tzatziki base topped with tomato, lettuce, and your choice of chicken or gyro meat. FYI: their gyro is a mixture of beef & lamb. I couldn't decide on which, so the person on the phone suggested splitting the pie with each option on a side. While both are delectable, I preferred the gyro topping. The taste of the beef/lamb meshes perfectly with everything else on the pie. Perfection. They even labeled the box to correspond with the topping on each side, a very nice touch as you may have a hard time telling amidst the veggies. I got a medium size pie and felt it was well-sized, but you can't go wrong with large. Also ordered a gyro and as Gen-Z likes to say: "it slaps." Plenty of meat, a good amount of tzatziki, along with onion and tomato wrapped in pillowy pita. Boo wanted to try the tyropita, which is a fried cheese wrapped in filo dough. I only had one bite but it was bangin (as we millennials and maybe younger gen-x used to say). Cheesy, a little salty, and a little pungency you like in a cheese. The gyro comes with fries which were pretty good despite being soggy. Next time I will ask for some tzatziki on the side to dip those in. Also got a Greek custard for Nikki. I'm sure it'll be great. All in all, I put away 2 slices of Greek pizza and demolished my gyro, and I have no regrets! 5 stars all day, come down to Pi today! ”